Farewell, 2023

The 16 Best Things I Ate This Year

And only two of them were pizza.

By Allecia Vermillion December 27, 2023

Every year, I start this process by scrolling back through the camera roll on my phone. Inevitably I have two reactions: 1. Wow, that's a lot of food. 2. A year is a long time. So many great meals and great moments speed by in a blur; it's nice to recall the dishes that truly stood out. Some were part of indulgent tasting menus; others were consumed in my car. They add up to a year full of work and pleasure—full of pizza, pastries, and the occasional fistful of sea urchin. Here's hoping 2024 can live up to its predecessor.


Rosette at Atoma

Wallingford

Chef Johnny Courtney uses cookie molds that once belonged to his wife (and business partner) Sarah's grandfather. But instead of a traditional Scandinavian dessert, you get a savory cookie, its hollow underside filled with Walla Walla onion jam and a bit of cheese. These are too small to share gracefully, but your own personal rosette is a lovely start to dinner at 2023’s most compelling new restaurant.

I am always that jerk who asks for a half-and-half pizza topping situation.

Tavern-Style Pizza at Windy City Pie

Phinney Ridge

If you’ve had Dave Lichterman’s deep-dish, you get a sense of the amount of R&D this man must complete before he puts his pizzas forth into the world. Ditto his tavern-style, with its crackery-thin crust and perfect ratio of cheese and sauce.

Omakase at Takai by Kashiba

Bellevue

I’ve been fortunate enough to have this very expensive experience a few times now. I considered putting a single bite on this list. (The octopus karaage? The soup course?) But the joy of this meal is its totality, each course outwardly simple but exuding technique. Seattle is having this amazing sushi moment, but my favorite spot now lives across the bridge in Bellevue.

Breakfast Sandwich at Ben's Bread Co.

Phinney Ridge

You have to appreciate a baker who was on the vanguard of working with local grains, but who also knows there’s a time and a place for a slice of processed American cheese. And that place is inside his breakfast sandwich. An impeccable english muffin holds a square of souffle’d egg, smooth as custard, and melty yellow cheese. Bacon if you want it. Come early—you’re gonna wait in line for this.

Tomato Salad at Pancita

Ravenna

This summer beauty is long gone from the menu, but it’s a spot-on example of why Pancita is special. Take a seasonal staple—an heirloom tomato salad—and add tomatillos, a salsa macha with morta chiles, and a bright salsa verde made with parsley. Now drape the whole thing with quesillo. The result is still Mexican, but also Northwest, thoroughly inventive and memorable all these months later.

Desserts at Driftwood

Alki

Disclosure: I ran into someone I knew on one of my visits to this lovely Alki newcomer. She had two desserts sent over to our table; otherwise I would have walked out the door without trying the hazelnut pie and chocolate olive oil cake. Those relatively simple descriptions don’t do justice to the confections. I hate fussy desserts; these two taste like something grandma theoretically made, but turbocharged with a ton of extra steps. Easily the best restaurant desserts I had this year.

Oysters at Hama Hama Oyster Saloon

Lilliwaup

A surefire way to entertain a visiting friend from LA: clear your calendar, get in the car, and head to the fifth-generation oyster farm on Hood Canal. When the pandemic drove us all outdoors, Hama Hama added some wooden A-frames and upped its menu game. Its oysters taste spectacular no matter where you are, but descending upon a freshly shucked platter outside, with a view of the water from whence they came is a singular Northwest experience.

Oklahoma Smash at Smash That Burger

Lower Queen Anne

The trend factor on smash burgers means there are a lot of them out there that are smashed in name only. This yellow truck parked outside Rooftop Brewing delivers lacy-edged, patty-crusted, hot-and-griddled greatness.

Khao Soi Chiang Mai at E-Jae Pak Mor

Chinatown–International District

The labor-heavy pak mor dumplings might be the signature dish (and they’re great). But I’d come back day after day for one of the city’s finest bowls of khao soi, full of curry, texture, and polished flavor.

Normie Macdonald Slice at Stevie's Famous

Burien

I had a great conversation with co-owner Shane Abbott for this story, then bought a slice on my way out the door. Even as a rapidly cooling slice consumed in my car, this pizza rocked my world. The balance of coppa, burrata, and hot honey was just right, especially atop a crust that demands respect.

Croissant Sobrasada Roll at MariPili Tapas Bar

Capitol Hill

Alas, Seattle Met’s 2022 Restaurant of the Year has discontinued its brunch service. But this savory creation will live on in my memory: a pinwheel of house croissant dough with a spreadable sausage filling and jamon bechamel on top. It was a life-giving, nap-inducing morning meal. Chef Grayson Corrales still makes this dish for special events. Another brunch favorite, the Spanish “french toast” appears on the dinner menu in savory form.

Bozena Shero at Delish Ethiopian Cuisine

Hillman City

Shiro (or shero) wat, the thick and simmered chickpea stew, is a pinnacle comfort food. Chef Amy Abera makes a version that adds beef tips, sauteed and spicy. Now it’s comfort food for grown-ups who enjoy good spice. I could eat this dish every day—though that’s true of most of the menu at this lovely spot Abera runs with her husband, Delish Lemma.

Urchin at L'Oursin

First Hill

I can't bring myself to go out on Valentine's Day, but my husband and I do attempt a nice dinner during some February-adjacent date. Nine times out of 10 we end up at L'Oursin. And if I'm lucky they have a supply of fresh urchin you can scoop straight from the spiny shell and eat with bread and butter. People, we are so fortunate to have seafood like this in our backyard. We are also fortunate that L'Oursin still serves the pimento cheese from its Old Scratch popup days. Because why not chase your uni with some spicy spreadable cheese?

Tomato, Plum, and Lemon Verbena at Tomo

White Center

This restaurant is not going to be everybody's jam, but it is very much mine. A semi-impromptu dinner in October was a rare tasting menu where every course felt like a highlight. But I still marvel at the kitchen's ability to wield ingredients like lemon verbena with such precision. And hot damn, the things Tomo does with produce.

Miki Noodles at Archipelago

Hillman City

It's tough to get a reservation at Aaron Verzosa and Amber Manuguid's 12-seat spot. And 1,000 percent worth it if you do. The menu generally includes some version of house miki noodles, hand-rolled, hand-cut, and made with local wheat. This time around it was sourdough, made with a wheat variety grown by a retired professor in Bellingham. On this night, they came gilded with house-cut bacon longanisa and a chili sarciado sauce made with preserved tomatoes and fermented peppers from nearby Kamayan Farm. The magic of Archipelago is bigger than any one dish, but this is the one my thoughts usually turn to.

Churro at Taco Time

Various

What can I say—they got to me. These new-to-the-menu churros, made by Edmonds-based bakery Alberto's Churros will exit testing phase and be at all Taco Time locations in the new year.

Share
Show Comments